Government scare tactics

Other topics - beer-related or not.
schutz
Posts: 11
Joined: Sunday Jan 15, 2006 6:58 pm

Government scare tactics

Post by schutz »

tonight on the news they are saying drinking even 1 beer a day will increase your chance of cancer by 11%.
The salvation army wants warning labels on beer containers as they do on cigerette packets.
Is this just another brainwashing new world order tactic thing by the government to stop drunks or what,becuase beer is just 98% water and all it can't be that bad
User avatar
lethaldog
Posts: 2716
Joined: Wednesday Jul 19, 2006 11:13 am
Location: Victoria

Post by lethaldog »

Tell me something these days that cant give you cancer!
so far ive heard dust, potatoes, MDF, red meat, smoking(derr), etc etc
As we all have cancer in us im guessing almost anything we put in our bodys could possibly set it off :lol: :lol: As im a smoker im not to concerned about my beer im sure the durrys will get me first :lol: :lol:
schutz
Posts: 11
Joined: Sunday Jan 15, 2006 6:58 pm

Re: Government scare tactics

Post by schutz »

schutzstaffel wrote:tonight on the news they are saying drinking even 1 beer a day will increase your chance of cancer by 11%.
The salvation army wants warning labels on beer containers as they do on cigerette packets.
Is this just another brainwashing new world order tactic thing by the government to stop drunks or what,becuase beer is just 98% water and all it can't be that bad
i forgot to mention i just bottled about 60 litres of beer yesterday so will i have to tip it all down the drain as it will kill me?
User avatar
lethaldog
Posts: 2716
Joined: Wednesday Jul 19, 2006 11:13 am
Location: Victoria

Re: Government scare tactics

Post by lethaldog »

schutzstaffel wrote:
schutzstaffel wrote:tonight on the news they are saying drinking even 1 beer a day will increase your chance of cancer by 11%.
The salvation army wants warning labels on beer containers as they do on cigerette packets.
Is this just another brainwashing new world order tactic thing by the government to stop drunks or what,becuase beer is just 98% water and all it can't be that bad
i forgot to mention i just bottled about 60 litres of beer yesterday so will i have to tip it all down the drain as it will kill me?

LET IT KILL I SAY :lol: :lol: id be happy to relieve you of it if your gonna throw it out, i love the cancerous little buggers :lol: :lol: :lol:
schutz
Posts: 11
Joined: Sunday Jan 15, 2006 6:58 pm

Post by schutz »

lethaldog wrote:Tell me something these days that cant give you cancer!
so far ive heard dust, potatoes, MDF, red meat, smoking(derr), etc etc
As we all have cancer in us im guessing almost anything we put in our bodys could possibly set it off :lol: :lol: As im a smoker im not to concerned about my beer im sure the durrys will get me first :lol: :lol:
i guess you are right....the teflon on my fry pan might get me before beer or the microwave :roll:
Anzac Cookies
Posts: 194
Joined: Wednesday Aug 02, 2006 6:40 pm
Location: Melbourne
Contact:

Re: Government scare tactics

Post by Anzac Cookies »

schutzstaffel wrote:
schutzstaffel wrote:tonight on the news they are saying drinking even 1 beer a day will increase your chance of cancer by 11%.
The salvation army wants warning labels on beer containers as they do on cigerette packets.
Is this just another brainwashing new world order tactic thing by the government to stop drunks or what,becuase beer is just 98% water and all it can't be that bad
i forgot to mention i just bottled about 60 litres of beer yesterday so will i have to tip it all down the drain as it will kill me?
You can only do that if your drain is connected to my fridge :lol: :lol: :lol:
A woman walks into a bar and orders a double entendre, so the bartender gave her one !
User avatar
Boonie
Posts: 1760
Joined: Friday Jul 21, 2006 6:41 pm
Location: Lake Macquarie

Post by Boonie »

Just watch out for that Peanut Butter, it causes cancer. Aluminium causes, um ,um ,um ,um what do you call it oh yeah Alzheimers.

Dont breath now as there is CO2 in the air :shock:

Give me a break.

My old smoked for 43 years and finally gave it up, and that was at over a pack a day, not the pussy smokes either, Rothmans and Winfield Reds. Now tell me that they cause Cancer. My old man is a living specimen.
All this typing and I am an ex-smoker who is supposed to whinge about smokers? :shock:

As people have said on this thread, we are born with it, just like Meningicoccal at the back of our throat.
:wink:

My liver will pack it in before the Cancer gets me :lol:
A homebrew is like a fart, only the brewer thinks it's great.
Give me a flying headbutt.......
User avatar
lethaldog
Posts: 2716
Joined: Wednesday Jul 19, 2006 11:13 am
Location: Victoria

Post by lethaldog »

Boonie wrote:Just watch out for that Peanut Butter, it causes cancer. Aluminium causes, um ,um ,um ,um what do you call it oh yeah Alzheimers.

Dont breath now as there is CO2 in the air :shock:

Give me a break.

My old smoked for 43 years and finally gave it up, and that was at over a pack a day, not the pussy smokes either, Rothmans and Winfield Reds. Now tell me that they cause Cancer. My old man is a living specimen.
All this typing and I am an ex-smoker who is supposed to whinge about smokers? :shock:

As people have said on this thread, we are born with it, just like Meningicoccal at the back of our throat.
:wink:

My liver will pack it in before the Cancer gets me :lol:
:lol: :lol: :lol: I only no of one exception in my lifetime, my nan she died this year at 81 and smoked heavily since she was 15, she didnt have cancer she just had a hearty and pretty much died on the spot, no suffering with cancer oh and she also loved a drink :lol: Hope i have plenty of her genes in me :lol: :lol:
blandy
Posts: 520
Joined: Saturday Jun 17, 2006 9:43 am
Location: Melbourne, Australia

Post by blandy »

11% greater than what? How many people in their control group drank?

There have been studies on coffee that showed similar results. Fortunately, some smart guy looked through the data collection methods and found that they didn't control for smoking.

Now I'm not saying that alcohol is totally safe, anyone who lives under that dillusion will have their genes removed from the pool early, but there are often flaws in studies like this.

For example, with these coffee studies, they later found that out of everyone taking part in the "experiment," ALL of the smokers were in the coffee-drinking group. Does that seem surprising? I mean, it's pretty hard to find a smoker who doesn't drink coffee (or alcohol for that matter), not that it's impossible though.

As for me, I love my beer and my coffee, but only have a bit each day, and sometimes I stick with un-enhanced water. Alcohol abuse is a big problem, and of course the risks need to be expressed so people can make informed descisions. But scare tactics are unnessisary.
I left my fermenter in my other pants
User avatar
lethaldog
Posts: 2716
Joined: Wednesday Jul 19, 2006 11:13 am
Location: Victoria

Post by lethaldog »

Im guessing your a smoker blandy :lol: :lol:

Good point though m8, you really have to take into account alot of factors, even the suburbs ppl live in could mean they are a greater risk, of the studies i would really like to know how many were smokers, lived in citys also what there eating habits are like, if they drink coffee or tea, how many use drugs, prescription or otherwise etc etc.

Also id like to ask if anyone else has noticed that all of these rediculous claims only ever come to light at the end of a financial year :shock:
I think that maybe government funding could possibly have something to do with this maybe :wink: :lol: :lol:
User avatar
Trizza
Posts: 248
Joined: Tuesday Sep 12, 2006 5:02 pm
Location: Luxembourg

Post by Trizza »

Every time I drink beer, I know it's probably cutting my life short by a few seconds.
Does that make me want to stop? f--- No!

You can go through life concerned with all the terrible effects that drinking alcohol and live a boring life.
Having fun and enjoying some of life's pleasures may take about 5-20 years off the end of your life, but were you really going to do anything with those years anyway?
Got Malt?
blandy
Posts: 520
Joined: Saturday Jun 17, 2006 9:43 am
Location: Melbourne, Australia

Post by blandy »

lethaldog wrote:Im guessing your a smoker blandy :lol: :lol:
Nope

I've just had to do lots to statistics in my Engineering/Commece degree and I understand how you can get f@#$ed up results if you're not careful.

BTW, I've got a friend doing a viticulture (sp?) course ATM. He told me that one of their tutors gave advice to the smokers in the class to quit. Not for health reasons, but because it wrecked their tastebuds and they couldn't taste their wine properly.

Anything that will significantly lower my appreciation of beer is definately out for me.
I left my fermenter in my other pants
User avatar
lethaldog
Posts: 2716
Joined: Wednesday Jul 19, 2006 11:13 am
Location: Victoria

Post by lethaldog »

blandy wrote:
lethaldog wrote:Im guessing your a smoker blandy :lol: :lol:
Nope

I've just had to do lots to statistics in my Engineering/Commece degree and I understand how you can get f@#$ed up results if you're not careful.

BTW, I've got a friend doing a viticulture (sp?) course ATM. He told me that one of their tutors gave advice to the smokers in the class to quit. Not for health reasons, but because it wrecked their tastebuds and they couldn't taste their wine properly.

Anything that will significantly lower my appreciation of beer is definately out for me.
:lol: :lol: :lol: Well i am a smoker and i can taste my beer just fine, i know this to be true but i dont seem to be to badly effected, the way i see it is you could not smoke, drink or do anything you enjoy and walk out the door and be shot or hit by lightning,run over by a car/bus/truck, stay at home your whole life and have intruders stab you to death etc etc, in my opinion enjoy life while you can cos you cant pick your way out (unless your suicidal) and we are not here for very long :lol: :wink:
Each to their own as to how they enjoy it to :lol:
User avatar
gregb
Moderator
Posts: 2620
Joined: Saturday Sep 25, 2004 9:12 am
Location: Sydney

Post by gregb »

Any half decent spin doctor can make the statistics say what ever you need them to say.

Being alive is a terminal disease.

There appears to be enough evidence to indicate that moderate consumption of beer and wine is beneficial to ones health.

I'll take my chances with the beer.

Smokes on the other hand, there is no evidence to indicate any health benefits, and a whole bunch to indicate they are bad for you.

Cheers,
Greg
drtom
Posts: 311
Joined: Thursday Mar 16, 2006 2:53 pm
Location: Preston, Melbourne

Post by drtom »

There was an article in today's Age which I didn't read, but the blurb on the front page of the web site said a study had found that people who drink are richer than people who don't. Sounded good to me. Cheers!

T.
Enjoying a (bought) dunkelweizen.
User avatar
lethaldog
Posts: 2716
Joined: Wednesday Jul 19, 2006 11:13 am
Location: Victoria

Post by lethaldog »

Smokes on the other hand, there is no evidence to indicate any health benefits, and a whole bunch to indicate they are bad for you.

Damn and i thought they were like vitamins :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
pacman
Posts: 254
Joined: Monday May 29, 2006 11:02 am
Location: Toowoomba Qld

Post by pacman »

We are all here (on Earth) on temporary visas. We should all make the most of our time here, on the proviso that we do not deprive others of the same rights.

The "do gooders" cannot "see the wood for the trees", but most of them are employed in government funded growth industries, and will not go away! Dammit! To their chagrin, most of their fellow citizens, in their blissful ignorance, simply ignore them.

I am often tempted to do battle with these "do gooders", and then I think why? What is the point? Absolute waste of time, so I have another HB. Or a glass of wine. Or a Cuban (or Central American) cigar.

Going to have another HB right now.
Cheers,

Pacman
User avatar
Boonie
Posts: 1760
Joined: Friday Jul 21, 2006 6:41 pm
Location: Lake Macquarie

Post by Boonie »

pacman wrote:We are all here (on Earth) on temporary visas. We should all make the most of our time here, on the proviso that we do not deprive others of the same rights.

The "do gooders" cannot "see the wood for the trees", but most of them are employed in government funded growth industries, and will not go away! Dammit! To their chagrin, most of their fellow citizens, in their blissful ignorance, simply ignore them.

I am often tempted to do battle with these "do gooders", and then I think why? What is the point? Absolute waste of time, so I have another HB. Or a glass of wine. Or a Cuban (or Central American) cigar.

Going to have another HB right now.
I'll drink to that :D and that :D and that :D awww ok and that :D
A homebrew is like a fart, only the brewer thinks it's great.
Give me a flying headbutt.......
Tourist
Posts: 176
Joined: Wednesday Mar 01, 2006 11:36 am
Location: Canberra

Re: Government scare tactics

Post by Tourist »

schutzstaffel wrote:Is this just another brainwashing new world order tactic thing by the government to stop drunks or what
Wouldn't be the government - too many tax $ in beer. They want us to drink up! And smoke-em if you've got-em, too.
User avatar
lethaldog
Posts: 2716
Joined: Wednesday Jul 19, 2006 11:13 am
Location: Victoria

Re: Government scare tactics

Post by lethaldog »

Tourist wrote:
schutzstaffel wrote:Is this just another brainwashing new world order tactic thing by the government to stop drunks or what
Wouldn't be the government - too many tax $ in beer. They want us to drink up! And smoke-em if you've got-em, too.
the government are the ones who put the warnings on smokes and the adds about it on tv :lol: :wink:
Post Reply